Skip to content

Tax year 2026

Five mistakes that overstate an OBBBA deduction estimate

The phase-out, rounding and filing-status rules in Schedule 1-A that are easy to get backwards — each one traced to the statute or the form itself.

Published October 8, 2026 · updated October 8, 2026

Schedule 1-A is new, and a handful of its rules run against what most people would reasonably guess. None of them are obscure once you read the form itself, but all five show up in estimates that come out too high — which matters more than an estimate that comes out too low, because the gap only surfaces when the actual return is filed. This guide walks through each one with the line of the form or the statute that settles it, so you can check your own numbers against the source rather than against a tool you cannot see inside.

1. The phase-out shrinks the deduction, not the cap

It is tempting to read a phase-out as lowering the ceiling itself — as if earning more simply bought a smaller cap to aim for. That is not the mechanism. The full deduction is worked out first, up to the cap, and only then is a phase-out subtracted from it.

Treasury’s own worked example makes the order unambiguous: ten thousand dollars of qualifying tips, for a filer with MAGI of a hundred and eighty thousand dollars, produces a deduction of seven thousand dollars — the cap was never in play, because ten thousand dollars did not approach it. The phase-out applied directly to the tip amount. A reader who treats the threshold as a shrinking cap, rather than a reduction applied afterward, will get the right answer near the cap and the wrong one everywhere else.

2. The senior deduction tapers per person, not per couple

The senior deduction is $6,000 per qualifying individual, reduced by 6% of the MAGI over the threshold for that one amount — not applied once to a combined household figure. On a joint return where both spouses are 65 or older, each spouse’s $6,000 is tapered on its own and the two results are added, which is a smaller reduction than tapering the doubled figure in one step would produce. Schedule 1-A enters the two amounts separately for exactly this reason — treat them as one household total during the taper and the household loses money it was entitled to keep.

3. A qualifying surviving spouse is not “married filing jointly”

Five filing statuses exist on a 2026 return, and the one most often typed wrong is qualifying surviving spouse. A QSS return takes the joint standard deduction and rate table, but Schedule 1-A’s “if married filing jointly” language does not stretch to cover it — so the overtime deduction caps at $12,500 for a QSS filer, not $25,000. The same split applies to the tips and senior deductions. Picking “married filing jointly” because it is the closest-sounding option on a dropdown is the most common way this deduction gets overstated by filers who do, correctly, qualify for something.

4. The car loan phase-out rounds against you

Tips and overtime round a partial thousand-dollar step down, so a MAGI that sits just over a threshold by a small amount costs nothing extra until the next full step is crossed. The car loan interest deduction does the opposite: its phase-out rounds a partial step up, so crossing the threshold by even one dollar triggers the full $200 reduction for that $1,000 increment. It is the only one of the four deductions that rounds this way, which makes it the one place on the form where a dollar of extra income is genuinely expensive.

5. “Through 2029” is one year too many

All four Schedule 1-A deductions run from 2025 through 2028 unless Congress extends them — not through a year later. The slip is an easy one to make, since nearby provisions of the same law use other sunset years, and 2028 sits close enough to round numbers that an extra year reads as plausible rather than as an obvious error. Worth checking directly against the statute if a figure you are relying on names a different final year.

Checking your own numbers

Each of these rules is also what runs underneath this site’s own calculators, reading from the same data these figures are pulled from — the tips eligibility checker, the overtime calculator, the senior deduction calculator and the car loan interest deduction tool all apply the phase-out, the per-person taper, the five filing statuses and the rounding direction the same way, so there is nowhere for the arithmetic to quietly diverge from what is written here.

Sources

Found an error in one of these figures? Report it.